Reciprocity in Online Markets: Empirical Studies of Auction and Barter Markets
نویسنده
چکیده
Title of Document: RECIPROCITY IN ONLINE MARKETS: EMPIRICAL STUDIES OF AUCTION AND BARTER MARKETS Shun Ye, Doctor of Philosophy, 2013 Directed By: Professor Siva Viswanathan, Department of Decision, Operations and Information Technologies Professor Il-Horn Hann, Department of Decision, Operations and Information Technologies My dissertation seeks to understand how reciprocity affects transaction outcomes and mechanism design in online markets. The first essay examines negative reciprocity illustrated as feedback-revoking behavior in the eBay auction market, focusing on its impact and implications for reputation system design. I utilize the biggest policy change of eBay’s reputation system in its history as a natural experiment setting to infer the causal impact of the reputation system on seller behavior. I find that strategic engagement in negative reciprocity enables low quality sellers to manipulate their reputations and masquerade as high-quality sellers. I further show that these sellers react strongly to eBay’s announcement of a ban on revoking. Interestingly, disallowing negative reciprocity motivates these sellers to significantly improve their service quality. The second essay examines positive reciprocity in one of the leading online barter markets for books, focusing on participants’ different reciprocity strategies and their impacts on transaction outcomes. I find that, whereas market participants who use the immediate reciprocity strategy are able to motivate higher service quality for the current transaction from the other partner, participants who use the delayed reciprocity strategy derive more benefits for future transactions by fulfilling their wishlists sooner. I further show that the market participants can be segmented into different reciprocity strategies based on their book avidness, breadth of interest, and psychographic profiles. Overall, the two studies provide important theoretical and practical implications for the design and regulation of online markets. RECIPROCITY IN ONLINE MARKETS: EMPIRICAL STUDIES OF AUCTION AND BARTER MARKETS
منابع مشابه
Probabilistic GENCOs Bidding Strategy in Restructured Two-Side Auction Power Markets
As a matter of course, power market uncertainties escalation is by product of power industry restructure on one hand and the unrivalled penetration of renewable energies on the other. Generally, the decision making process in such an uncertain environment faces with different risks. In addition, the performance of real power markets is very close to oligopoly markets, in which, some market play...
متن کاملInformation Transparency in B2B Auction Markets: The Role of Winner Identity Disclosure
We study the impact of information transparency in B2B auctions. Specifically, we measure the effect of concealing winners’ identities on auction outcomes using a large-scale, quasi-natural field experiment. Contrary to the conventional wisdom that “the more information, the better,” we find that concealing winners’ identities leads to a significant increase in price by approximately 6%, and su...
متن کاملMarket structure and quality uncertainty: a theoretical framework for online auction research
Given large numbers of buyers and sellers, with access to a wide variety of information, economic theory suggests that online auction markets should provide an efficient mechanism for establishing equilibrium prices. Previous research on online auction prices, however, is far from conclusive, having produced mixed findings. The seemingly inconsistent and sometimes contradictory results make it ...
متن کاملSellers in Online Auction Markets: Introducing a Feedback-Based Classification
Increasing significance of the online consumer-to-consumer (C-2-C) auction market has amplified the need for buyers and sellers to engage in transactions with anonymous counterparts. The sequence of paying first and then taking delivery, introduces a great amount of risk for potential buyers. In order to mitigate this risk, online auction markets (OAMs) are employing an assortment of governance...
متن کاملE-commerce Auction Agents and Online-auction Dynamics
Online-auctions are one of the most successful types of electronic markets. They bring together buyers and sellers on a massive scale. However, using an electronic medium for conducting auctions has fundamental differences from traditional English-style auctions. One difference is the availability of software agents that can facilitate many aspects of online-auction participation. The addition ...
متن کامل